top of page

DESTROY AN ENTIRE CITY?

The weight of deciding a city's fate is not borne lightly; it echoes with the profound gravity of divine judgment and human consequence. * On the second reading of Parshas Vayeira with integrated commentary inspired by Rashi.

by Rabbi Boruch Merkur

The sun hung low in the sky, casting its golden hue across the quiet expanse of Abraham and Sarah's tent. The promise of a son had been declared by the divine messengers, and the laughter of incredulity had escaped Sarah's lips. Yet, when questioned, she denied her own laughter, concealing her true feelings with a faint smile.


In the stillness of that moment, a profound exchange took place—a dialogue not just between husband and wife, but between faith and doubt, between the human heart and the divine plan. Sarah, with her wisdom and experience, had her doubts, and fear had momentarily crept into her heart. She questioned how such a miracle could come to be when she and her husband were advanced in years.


And so, she hesitated to fully embrace the angel's words. But the divine messenger, perceiving the nuance in her response, gently corrected her. "You did laugh," he affirmed, not as an accusation, but as a revelation of the truth.


In this exchange, we see the interplay of doubt and faith, of human vulnerability and divine assurance. Sarah's laughter, at first a product of disbelief, would soon transform into the laughter of joy as the miracle of a long-awaited child would come to pass. It is a reminder that sometimes, even in the face of uncertainty, the promises of the Divine unfold in ways that exceed our comprehension, bringing forth joy and wonder beyond our wildest dreams.


*


The amber light of the setting sun cast a golden glow over the landscape, intensifying the atmosphere of unease. As Abraham watched, the men rose from their position, casting their gaze toward the city of Sodom. This wasn't a mere casual glance; their intense scrutiny hinted at an ominous undertone. Historically, such a focused look held the weight of foreboding, a signal of impending disaster.


Yet, in Abraham's heart, these men were not just divine beings; they appeared to him as travelers on a journey. Unaware of the gravity of their mission and the depth of their intent, Abraham's sense of hospitality prevailed. Moved by the age-old tradition of accompanying guests, he walked beside them, his steps mirroring their stride, ensuring they were given a proper send-off. The ancient custom of escorting visitors wasn't merely a gesture of courtesy; it was a sign of deep respect and consideration.


As they moved forward, side by side, the contrast was striking: the righteousness of Abraham against the backdrop of the wicked city of Sodom. What was to come next would test the very fabric of faith and morality. The journey ahead held tales of righteousness and wickedness, of divine judgment, and the undying hope for mercy.


*


In the warm hues of the evening, the golden sun hung low over the horizon, casting long shadows over the expansive plains of Canaan. Abraham, the chosen patriarch, sat deep in contemplation outside his tent. The air was thick with anticipation.


A gentle breeze whispered secrets as it rustled through the trees. It seemed as though the heavens themselves were opening up for a moment of divine introspection. The Lord pondered, "הַמְכַסֶּ֤ה אֲנִי֙" ("Shall I conceal?") from Abraham what was about to transpire in the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah.


Abraham had forged an unbreakable bond with the Divine. This land, stretching far and wide beneath the azure sky, had been promised to him. The cities that dotted the landscape, particularly the five renowned ones, were his by divine decree. "And the border of the Canaanite was from Sidon…, as you come to Sodom and Gomorrah..." They were more than just territories; they were symbols of his pact with the Almighty. The name Abraham, meaning the father of a multitude of nations, wasn't just a title; it was a responsibility.


The Lord contemplated further, realizing the depth of His bond with Abraham. Could He destroy the children of these cities without confiding in their patriarch, especially when Abraham had shown Him such unwavering love and devotion?


The gravity of the decision weighed heavily. It wasn't just about the fate of the cities; it was about trust, understanding, and the sanctity of a bond forged in faith. The impending doom of Sodom and Gomorrah was not just a divine act, but a narrative that intertwined with the destiny of Abraham and his descendants. The tale of the cities' fate would forever be etched in history, a testament to the choices made and the trust placed in the bonds of the heart.


*


In a time where the world felt vast and uncharted, Abraham, with his unwavering faith, stood as a ray of hope. There was something remarkable about him; a magnetic force that drew people in, whispering of a future filled with promise.


On a sunlit day, the skies painted in hues of blue and gold, a voice proclaimed, "Abraham, you will be the cornerstone of a powerful nation. Your legacy will resonate through the ages, like the ripples of a stone cast upon still waters."


The Hebrew words "לְג֥וֹי גָּד֖וֹל וְעָצ֑וּם" translated to "a great and powerful nation", echoed the magnitude of this prophecy. The profoundness of these words wasn’t just about sheer numbers or might. It was about influence and the ability to inspire. It meant that through Abraham, blessings would flow to the furthest reaches of the earth, touching every heart and soul.


It wasn't by mere chance or luck that such words were spoken about Abraham. His righteousness was his signature. Just as when one mentions the beauty of a rose, its fragrance is remembered, the mention of Abraham brought forth blessings. It was said, "זֵכֶר צַדִּיק לִבְרָכָה", meaning "The mention of a righteous man is for a blessing."


Yet, behind the layers of praise and prophecy, was a simpler, heartwarming sentiment. The voice mused, "Should I keep secrets from Abraham? He's so dear to me." It was a testimony to their special bond. The world was about to witness the rise of a nation, but at the heart of it all, was a bond between the Divine and a man named Abraham.


*


In the bustling streets of Ur, Abraham was unlike any other. His journey, however, wasn't a lonesome one, for the divine hand that had reached out to him never let go.


For I have known him, echoed the voice from the heavens, a tone of deep affectionate familiarity, as if remarking on an old friend. In Hebrew, the sentiment was conveyed with the term "ידעתיו" - an expression denoting love and intimate recognition. Just as a person might draw closer to a loved one, cherishing their presence, the Divine had this profound connection with Abraham.


And why this affection? It wasn't merely because Abraham walked the path of righteousness. It was the promise he held for the future: he instructed his children and his entire household to follow the same path. Abraham’s passion wasn't just for his immediate kin. He envisioned a legacy, a lineage that would "keep the way of the Lord," perpetuating acts of righteousness and justice.


And there, amidst the tents and the vast stretches of desert, lay the cornerstone of this vision. Abraham didn't simply live his beliefs; he passed them on. In his daily actions and teachings, he ensured that his family would uphold these divine values, paving the way for generations to come.


This relationship was built on mutual understanding. As the heavens declared its intimate knowledge and affection for Abraham, it was clear: he was chosen not only for his personal virtues but for the promise he held for future generations. The Divine foresaw that through Abraham, a legacy of righteousness would be etched into the annals of time, ensuring that the divine promise would be realized through his descendants.


*


The heavens trembled as the Almighty spoke with Abraham. The divine voice carried the weight of a heavy decision, one that could shape the destiny of entire cities. God declared, "The outcry of Sodom and Gomorrah is great, and their sin is exceedingly grave."


In these words, hidden deep within the layers of meaning, there was a profound lesson. The Almighty, in His infinite wisdom, did not conceal the sins of these cities from Abraham. Instead, He revealed the magnitude of their transgressions. It was a stark reminder that righteousness and justice could not be compromised. Even a city with a great outcry could not escape the scales of divine judgment when its sins were too weighty.


The word "great" resonated with the severity of their deeds. It was not a minor transgression, nor a fleeting lapse in judgment. No, the outcry was great, echoing through the heavens, reaching the very throne of God. The sins committed within those walls had shaken the foundations of morality and justice.


The Almighty's decision to share this knowledge with Abraham was not incidental. It was a testament to the relationship between the Creator and His chosen one. God trusted Abraham with the knowledge of these grave sins, for He knew that Abraham's unwavering commitment to righteousness and justice would guide his response.


*


The sun was beginning to dip below the horizon, casting elongated shadows upon the ground. As the evening approached, a Divine proclamation resonated through the heavens, "I will descend now and see if the cries of the land match the tales of iniquity that have reached Me."


The statement was profound. The land itself seemed to wail in response to the deeds of its inhabitants. But God, in His infinite wisdom and fairness, didn't merely rely on these distant cries. He chose to get closer, to see for Himself and to understand the heart of the matter. This was a vital lesson, especially for those entrusted with the heavy responsibility of judgment. For even in human courts, when meting out the gravest of judgments, the judges must immerse themselves in the case, often visiting the site of the crime to grasp the full reality of what transpired.


The murmurs in the heavenly realm continued, contemplating the nature of the land's outcry. Was it a collective cry of its people? Or perhaps, was it echoing the singular cry of a young girl? A girl who, as the stories told, had met a cruel fate simply because she dared to feed a hungry soul?


The Divine voice pondered, "If these tales prove true, and the wickedness persists unabated, then destruction will be inevitable. However, if they show remorse or refrain from their defiant ways, I will reconsider. Even then, they may face repercussions, albeit less severe ones."


There was no rush to judgment. No hasty conclusions. God, in His infinite wisdom, sought clarity, understanding, and above all, justice. The fate of the city hung in the balance, with every action and intention poised to tip the scales. The narrative of the land's cries was still unfolding, and only time would reveal its ultimate outcome.


*


Amidst the desert’s warm embrace, Abraham continued in his gracious role as host, escorting the men some distance from his tent. With each step, the dust rose, forming silhouettes against the horizon. The three figures soon approached a crossroads. Here, the men took a decisive turn, their path veering towards Sodom, that city of notoriety. Yet, as the desert swallowed their footprints, a solitary figure remained, the shadow of Abraham still visible.


Despite the journey’s interruptions, Abraham's devotion never wavered. An onlooker might believe it was Abraham who had sought out a divine audience, but it was the reverse. The Holy One had approached Abraham, sharing the grave concerns about the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah. It's curious, then, that the scripture mentions Abraham as the one "still standing before the Lord" when one would expect it to be the other way around. Yet, there's a profound humility in the text, a subtle adjustment, reminding us of Abraham's unwavering faith and the depth of his relationship with the Divine.


Though the men continued towards their destiny in Sodom, Abraham remained rooted in place, deeply engrossed in his conversation with the Divine, seeking understanding, compassion, and perhaps a chance for redemption for those in the cities below. The weight of the moment, the gravity of the decisions to be made, hung in the air as Abraham continued his dialogue with the Almighty.


*


Abraham stood firm in the presence of the Lord, a solitary figure in the vast expanse of the desert. The divine messengers had gone on their way, heading toward the city of Sodom, but the righteous patriarch, the embodiment of unwavering faith and compassion, had not wavered. His heart brimmed with concern for the fate of the people of Sodom, even as he stood in the presence of the Almighty.


In that desolate moment, Abraham felt a surge of righteous indignation. He could not fathom the idea that the righteous might suffer the same fate as the wicked. With courage in his heart and determination in his voice, he approached the Lord and posed a question that would reverberate through the annals of time.


Will You sweep away the righteous with the wicked? he asked, his voice carrying the weight of a soul deeply troubled by the impending judgment.


The question hung in the air, a plea for justice, a plea for mercy. It was a question that transcended the immediate circumstances, touching upon the very nature of the divine. In those words, Abraham sought to challenge the conventional understanding of justice and righteousness, to plead for the lives of those who might still bear the spark of goodness, even in the darkest corners of the world.


And so, in the shadow of Sodom's impending doom, a conversation unfolded—an exchange of words that would test the boundaries of divine compassion and human righteousness. Abraham's bold inquiry echoed through the ages, a testament to the power of one person's unwavering faith and unwavering commitment to the pursuit of justice and compassion.


*


Abraham stood before the Almighty, his plea hanging in the air like a fragile thread of hope in the face of impending judgment. He had dared to question the divine, to challenge the fate of the wicked and the righteous alike. And now, in the hushed expanse of the desert, his voice rang out once more, filled with an unwavering determination.


Perhaps there are fifty righteous individuals within the city? Abraham's voice quivered with a mix of trepidation and hope. He had not given up on the people of Sodom, for he believed in the power of righteousness to redeem even the most wayward souls.


The Lord, in all His wisdom, considered Abraham's plea. The patriarch's words were not just a simple inquiry; they were a testament to his unshakable faith in the potential for goodness in humanity. In those words, he implored the divine to spare the city for the sake of those few righteous souls who might dwell within its walls.


And so, the conversation continued, a delicate negotiation between man and God, between justice and compassion. In the vast desert, the fate of an entire city hung in the balance, and Abraham's unwavering faith remained the guiding star in the night sky of uncertainty.


*


Abraham's voice resonated with fervor as he continued his plea, his words a testament to his unwavering commitment to justice and righteousness.


Far be it from You to do such a thing, he implored the Almighty. "To bring death upon the righteous along with the wicked, treating the just and the unjust alike. Far be it from You! Shall not the Judge of all the Earth act justly?"


Abraham's words were not a mere protest; they were an appeal to the very essence of divine justice. He knew that the Almighty, in His infinite wisdom, could discern between the righteous and the wicked. He challenged the notion that the righteous should suffer the same fate as the wicked, asserting that it was beneath the dignity of the Supreme Judge.


In the vast expanse of the desert, under the canopy of the starry night sky, Abraham stood as a beacon of righteousness and compassion. His plea echoed through the ages, a reminder that justice should always be tempered with mercy, and that the Judge of all the Earth should indeed act justly.


*


The divine exchange between Abraham and the Almighty continued to unfold in the stillness of the desert night. Abraham's plea had been passionate and unyielding, a testament to his unwavering commitment to justice and righteousness.


In response, the voice of the Almighty resonated with a solemn promise. "If I find within Sodom fifty righteous individuals in the midst of the city," the Divine voice declared, "I will spare the entire place for their sake."


Abraham, the righteous intercessor, had posed a profound challenge to the Almighty's plan. His plea was not merely for the fate of Sodom but for the very principles of justice and mercy. The stage was now set for a divine test, where the destiny of an entire city hung in the balance, and the Judge of all the Earth would reveal His unwavering commitment to justice and righteousness.


The night air was thick with anticipation, as the fate of Sodom and its inhabitants rested on the delicate scale of divine judgment.


*


Abraham, undeterred by the divine promise, raised his voice once more. "Behold," he proclaimed with unwavering humility, "I have embarked on a mission to speak before the Lord. Yet, I am but dust and ashes."


In his plea, Abraham invoked the image of his own humble origin, emphasizing his insignificance in the grand scheme of the universe. He saw himself as the very dust from which humanity had sprung, and the ashes that remained when the fire of life was extinguished.


But his humility was not a sign of weakness; it was a reflection of his profound understanding of the Almighty's greatness. He recognized that even a righteous intercessor, a man of profound faith, must approach the Divine presence with utmost humility.


As the night wore on, Abraham's words hung in the air, a testament to the depth of his devotion and the earnestness of his plea. The destiny of Sodom and its inhabitants still hung in the balance, and the Creator of All continued to listen, His divine judgment unfolding in the heart of the desert.


*


Abraham's voice, carrying the weight of a solemn covenant, echoed through the stillness of the desert night. He continued his impassioned plea, his words a bridge between the earthly realm and the divine.


Perhaps, Abraham implored, his voice laced with desperation, "there will be fifty righteous individuals within the city. Will You then sweep away the righteous with the wicked? Surely, O Lord, You, the ultimate Judge of all the earth, would not commit such an act."


Abraham's query hung in the air, his plea a testament to his unyielding faith in divine justice. He grappled with the notion that the righteous could be ensnared in the same fate as the wicked. His unwavering belief in the righteousness of the Almighty stirred the heavens, and his plea became a beacon of hope in the darkness.


But the response from the divine was not immediate, leaving Abraham to wait in anticipation, his heart heavy with the fate of the city and the destiny of the righteous souls within its walls.


*


Abraham's plea persisted, each word a prayer, each sentence a lifeline to the city of Sodom. The desert night held its breath as he beseeched the divine.


Could there perhaps be forty righteous individuals within the city? Abraham asked, his voice trembling with hope. "Will You then withhold Your divine judgment for their sake?"


Abraham's heart beat in tandem with his plea, his unwavering faith shining like a beacon. He considered the possibility that even a few righteous souls could sway the fate of an entire city, that the scales of justice could tip in their favor.


The heavens themselves seemed to pause in contemplation, and the answer hung in the air, as if the very universe held its breath.


*


Abraham's plea continued, each word a testament to his unwavering devotion. He implored, "If there are perhaps thirty righteous individuals within the city, will You then withhold Your divine judgment for their sake?"


It was a plea forged from the depths of his soul, a plea that dared to believe that even a small number of righteous souls could bring salvation to many. The night seemed to grow still, as if the very stars held their breath, awaiting the response from the heavens.


*


Abraham's voice trembled with hope as he continued his entreaty, saying, "Please, let me speak just once more, O Lord. What if only twenty righteous individuals can be found there?"


In that moment, the patriarch's words were like a beacon of light, a plea for mercy that pierced the darkness of impending judgment. The weight of his plea hung in the air, and the response from the divine awaited, as if the fate of an entire city balanced on the precipice of a single decision.


*


With each word, Abraham's plea grew more fervent, and the divine response seemed to hang in the balance, like a feather on the edge of a precipice. "Please, let not my Lord be angered," Abraham implored. "Let me speak just once more. What if only ten righteous souls can be found there?"


His voice was filled with both urgency and hope, a plea not just for mercy but for the preservation of the very essence of justice and compassion. It was as though the fate of a city rested upon the shoulders of ten individuals, a handful of righteous souls who, if found, could tip the scales of judgment.


The response, though unspoken, reverberated through the cosmos, as if the very heavens themselves held their breath, waiting to see if the plea of the righteous would be answered.


*


Amid the vastness of the desert, the intensity of the moment was palpable. The Lord, the eternal, omniscient force, had concluded His discourse with Abraham, a mere mortal yet a man of profound faith. The deep weight of their conversation hung in the air, punctuating the silence that followed their dialogue.


The scriptures recount, "And the Lord departed when He finished speaking to Abraham."


It was an interaction like no other. A dialogue between the divine and the human, two worlds momentarily converging. It wasn’t an abrupt end but a natural culmination, much like the setting sun signaling the close of day. In a realm beyond mortal comprehension, it was understood: once the advocate, Abraham, fell silent, there was no reason for the Judge to remain.


Abraham felt the divine presence recede, a subtle shift in the atmosphere. The deep connection they shared in those moments was unlike any other, a profound bond formed in the crucible of faith and destiny. With the Lord's departure, Abraham too knew it was time to move. He returned to his place, the familiar surroundings that held both his past and his future.


The scriptures depict the ensuing scene with a hint of foreboding: "And Abraham returned to his place." With the departure of both the Judge and the defender, an eerie stillness descended. It's as if the cosmic scales of justice were teetering, waiting for the next move. The accuser's voice, hidden but always present, began its lament, echoing with accusations.


The narrative continues its inevitable march: "And the two angels came to Sodom." Their purpose? To enact the divine plan, to bring judgment upon Sodom and salvation to Lot. It is said that one of these messengers was also responsible for healing Abraham. The third, having announced Isaac’s birth to Sarah, had already completed his mission and left.


Such is the ebb and flow of the divine narrative, where moments of intense connection are followed by action and consequence, where destinies are forged, and the future is set in motion.

5 views0 comments

Related Posts

See All

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

BRAND NEW RELEASE
of uncanny relevance to our time.

Gog & Magog

the war to end all wars, illustrated with original art and including a brand new translation of the interpretations of Malbim on Ezekiel.
Click here to order one now!

bottom of page